Outgoings in Retail Leases
Outgoings are additional “property” related costs that tenants may be required to pay on top of rent. In retail (and commercial) leases, these can include:
In Australia, retail leases are governed by state-specific legislation and what is considered outgoings is prescriptive. Beyond outlining what outgoings can be recovered by a landlord, the legislation also provides additional requirements e.g. the landlord must provide annual estimates of outgoings to the tenant prior to the commencement of each financial year.
Tenants and landlords of retail premises must have a clear understanding of their respective rights and obligations of what is payable and by whom, and what processes must be adhered to and followed.
What the retail leases legislation in each State prescribes as recoverable outgoings is final and overrides any provisions in a retail lease which is contrary to that legislation.
Outgoings are the costs a landlord incurs in running the premises or, in a multi-occupancy property such as a shopping centre, the centre as a whole. The Retail Leases Act defines them as the expenses directly attributable to operating, maintaining or repairing the building (or the centre and its common areas), plus the rates, taxes, levies, premiums and charges the landlord pays as owner or occupier.
Whether a lease is retail or commercial is a question of fact, decided by the definition of retail premises in the Act. For outgoings on a commercial lease that is not retail, what you pay largely comes down to what the lease says. If the premises are retail, the rules below apply as well, whatever the lease says.
Under the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic), the following cannot be recovered from a retail tenant:
A lease clause that says otherwise is void to the extent it is inconsistent with the Act.
Under section 39, a retail tenant only has to pay outgoings if the lease specifies which outgoings are recoverable, how the amount is worked out and apportioned, and how the landlord will recover them. If an outgoing is not listed, the landlord cannot charge it. For landlords, a drafting gap here can mean losing an outgoing on a technical point.
Section 46 requires the landlord to give the tenant an estimate of outgoings before the lease is entered into, and at least one month before the start of each financial year. Until the estimate is given, the tenant does not have to pay. In Phillips v Abel [2019] VCAT 1031, VCAT found that a landlord cannot go back and recover outgoings for a period before the estimate was provided.
The estimate does not have to be exact, and a tenant generally cannot refuse to pay because it turned out to be inaccurate. An estimate so far off that it could mislead the tenant may not count as a compliant estimate.
A tenant may also have to pay GST on outgoings, depending on whether the landlord is registered for GST and whether the supply is taxable.
For a new retail lease, the outgoings should already be set out in the disclosure statement for the retail lease, so compare the two before you commit. If outgoings have been overcharged or under-recovered, our retail lease lawyers can work out what is actually payable, or call 1300 907 335.
Commercial leases cover a broader range of properties, including offices, warehouses, and industrial spaces. Because commercial leases are not subject to or governed by any State leasing legislation, the outgoings which can be recovered under commercial leases are those which are negotiated and specified in the lease and are typically more extensive than retail leases. Such additional outgoings may include:
Negotiating outgoings in commercial leases can be more complex due to the diverse nature of commercial properties. Both landlords and tenants should carefully review the lease terms, in particular the payment of outgoings, to understand their respective obligations.
A lease lawyer will help to ensure that your lease is fundamentally correctly categorised as a retail or a commercial lease. This will determine what costs can and cannot be passed onto and recovered from the tenant.
Our lease lawyers have extensive experience in handling retail and commercial leases, including negotiation of lease terms, drafting the lease and undertaking any enforcement action for breach, including complex litigation. Our team is here to provide you with quality advice and representation on retail and commercial leases and leasing matters.
I appreciate your time and effort and thank you for your prompt response and professionalism. I would not hesitate to use your services again and refer PCL Lawyers to others.
Thank you so much for your assistance. Should I ever have the chance to recommend you I will do so.
Out of speaking to two other lawyers you were the only one to give me any genuine advice.
If I had of gone to another law firm that was cheaper I may have saved many thousands of dollars but as it turns out I may have lost a lot more than that upon settlement. Using a firm such as PCL lawyers I had the peace of mind that each issue as it arose was dealt with in a very matter of fact way and to the letter of the law.
PCL did a great job in advising me about my rights and protecting my name and business goodwill. I can absolutely recommend this very professional service.
Excellent Service. PCL Lawyers did a great job advising me about my rights and protecting my name and business goodwill. I can absolutely recommend this very professional service.